Recent 100% reliable CSDS survey found 87%people of Kashmir valley want full freedom. Shouldn't be respected?

CSDS survey has found that 87% people of Kashmir Valley want COMPLETE INDEPENDENCE as the solution of the problem of DISPUTED state, running from1947[actually the problem started on 16 th March,1846 as a result of human sale deed(Rs7per head)based imposition of Hidu monarchy by British against the wishes of people of state] b coz of dishonesty, injustices, treachery, fraudulent manipulation %26amp; subterfuge of Delhi's leaderships %26amp; dirty dilly dallying to postpone %26amp; keep state by hook or by crook without solution %26amp; saying unilaterally dat d dirty illegal actions were the substitutes of FREE %26amp; FAIR PLEBISCITE under UN auspices which was declared illegal by UNSC on January24, 1957. If a good taken by theft is with you for 60 years %26amp; by force you keep it dat does not justify ownership. By honesty %26amp; justice all Indian actions to destroy the autonomy of the state were illegal.We know better that 99% people want India out of their land. Must it not be respected or no principle is in India ?

Recent 100% reliable CSDS survey found 87%people of Kashmir valley want full freedom. Shouldn't be respected?
Kashmir was an independent state at the time of Independence. What ever happened after that was illegal and inhuman. India and Pakistan occupied equal parts of Kashmir and terrorizing every common man in Kashmir. Kashmir was swallowed by both countries towards war expenses.
Reply:Kashmir is an integral part of India and so are few states around India because they are geographically and culturally close and were unified in past.





Voting is not preferred because a lot of original Kashmiris were chased away from their home using terror tactics.





Why dont you promise next 20 years of no terror and killings and then conduct plebiscite after that , that would require lots of courage and honesty.





Your anger against BJP and RSS is understandable because they are pro-Hindu but lot of it is more from your perceived notion rather than truth. In fact you can go to an RSS branch and see what work they do.


During times of calamities they have helped people from ALL religions including Muslims too.





You are selectively taking only those news items which suit your idea.
Reply:A wonder full Q in time .The people of INDIA %26amp; PAKISTAN should take in mind .Kasmir matter is not A Hindu Muslim matter .the Kasmeris are fighting for thier fgreedom.the radical partries are using this as a platform for benifit of politics. Parties such as B J P ,R S S ,.further more india had assuerd Kasmir more freedom in to the state but till never keep its words. they had changed the propaganda as radical issue.
Reply:it is the security related matters for the India.
Reply:Exactly that is the problem; 13% of people dont want full freedom. Majority desire should be respected or minority fears should be allayed? Partition between India and Pakistan saw, minority staying in India. For the sake of minorities, majority suffers here. If it is said, 'so, you also suffer', will it be acceptable? While composite India was invaded and ruled by Islam rulers, Muslim population should have been created. While so, correct history should tell us truth about how a Hindu Monarch was ruling Kashmir, if it is not part of India and how Muslims are 85% now.


'India and Pakistan', what Britain %26amp; Jinnah created, is maintained by Britain, US and China; Kashmir, from its problem point of view, is a miniature India.
Reply:Yahoo forum cannot solve this issue.Time is fast ripening for Kashmiris to prove that they would be FREE through the ballot.
Reply:You can even get 100% after driving away the remaining Hindus.
Reply:In all surveys it the one who pays the piper calls the tune





kashmir has enjoyed more freedom than other indian have enjoyed.





Kashmir has bled indian economy





Kashmiri can buy property anywhere while GOI can not construct high court in kashmir coz president is not a resident of kashmir





kashmir is personal property of nehru family.


every body wants freedom , but what is freedom and how it is be dealt with





what benefit kashmir confers on india economically, and politically





Benazir Bhutto once saidkashmir has lost significance with pakistani voters due to economic burden but not with indians is it media hype
Reply:Pakistanis got pakistan in 1947 being carved out of India, Bangladeshis got Bangladesh in 1972 by declaring their independence from the tyrannical rule of West Pakistan. There is no problem whatsoever if Kashmiris are conceded Kashmir by both India and pakistan. This is the only viable solution for this long pending contentious issue. But kashmiris have to understand that running a state and a independent country is not an easy ball game. Kashmir is a home for Muslims, Hindus, Sikhs and Buddhists and is adjoined by two nuclear powers namely India and pakistan, they have no port, no army, no defence equipment, no state treasury, no means of sustenance except to either depend on Pakistan or India. It is something easier said than done, all the pros and cons of the issue have to be considered before such a decision is arrived at. Until such time the Kashmiris have to keep on struggling.